Collector's Editions (X-Men and Captain America) Messages in this topic - RSS

angelochelsea
angelochelsea
Posts: 136

8/19/2025

angelochelsea
angelochelsea
Posts: 136
Hi,

Please can we edit one or both of these titles for consistency?

All 3 came out in 1981 and 1982. They both have the prefix "Marvel Presents The"....However, you have this for Captain America listing but not for the X-men listing. Unfortunately the indicia's on all 3 are no help at all. My view is that "Marvel Presents The" is unnecessary. You may of course have the counter view. Either way it just needs to be consistent please.


https://www.comicspriceguide.com/titles/x-men-collectors-edition/pcurn

https://www.comicspriceguide.com/titles/marvel-presents-the-captain-america-collectors-edition/unryi


Many thanks
0 link
collectibleshop
collectibleshop
Posts: 3088

8/19/2025

collectibleshop
collectibleshop
Posts: 3088
My feeling is that "Marvel Presents The" should be in the title listing, as that would be the name of the 'series' from that publisher, although it's the only one of it. Plus it'll be what most users will use to find it, even tho it will show up using just X-Men Collector's Edition and UK for the country choice. And for the Cap one, 'Collector's' should have an apostrophe in the listing title like the X-Men one does. They're from 2 different publishers, and if the indicia is no help, then the cover title is what should be used in my opinion. I see the 2nd HC for Cap says 'A Marvel' something, but can't make out the 3 word. But CPG's call to make.
edited by collectibleshop on 8/19/2025
0 link
angelochelsea
angelochelsea
Posts: 136

8/22/2025

angelochelsea
angelochelsea
Posts: 136
Hi, Just to confirm, from the indicia all 3 are are "MARVEL COMICS INTERNATIONAL LTD., a subsidiary of cadence Industries Corporation. Published in association with GRANDREAMS LTD"
0 link