Grading Whole Run Opinion Messages in this topic - RSS

Jasonkron
Jasonkron
Posts: 2

3/25/2019

Jasonkron
Jasonkron
Posts: 2
Sorry if this has been discussed, i'm still dipping my toes back into the water.

Long story short, my brother and I used to collect comics in the mid 80's until late 80's. We were true collectors and took care of everything. I'm looking to sell parts of the collection and obviously want to maximize the value.

Here is my question. I have Sandman 1-10 in what I believe is 9.4 or above quality. Assuming cost is not an issue, should I get all 10 books rated by CGC and then sell that way or just 1 and 8?

I appreciate the help and opinions.

Regards

JasonKron
0 link
Ronbatman
Ronbatman
Administrator
Posts: 2530

3/25/2019

Ronbatman
Ronbatman
Administrator
Posts: 2530
The first thing that you should do is study the books and try to find any flaws, blunt corners, spine creases, minor folds, etc. Look at the front and back cover for any issue. Every flaw can lower the grade of the book. I wouldn't send off any book that shows more than one very minor flaw. When those books get to 9.6 and below it isn't hardly worth the time and effort to get them professionally graded. (unless you just like graded books)

Welcome back to the hobby and please let us know how we can help you.
Ron
0 link
collectibleshop
collectibleshop
Posts: 3088

3/25/2019

collectibleshop
collectibleshop
Posts: 3088
after you've determined your grades, go do some research on SOLD CGC Sandman prices on 'that' auction site and other venues to get an idea of what they're going for in 9.4., 9.6., 9.8. Like Ron said, modern 9.4's often aren't worth grading, although #1s and 1st Appearances might be if in demand and valuable enough raw. Moderns under $200 graded value will cost you $20 plus shipping to and from the grading companies, so plan on adding a few dollars per book for that too. If the value is over $200 and under $400 you're going to have to pay $38 (for CGC anyway).
Looks like Sandman 1 in 9.8 is generally selling a little under $400, so you'd only have to pay $20 for grading. Looks like #1, #4, #8 are worth grading in 9.4 too. I saw some 9.8s of some of the others below 10 only getting $19.99, and up to $30, so not worth it, but there may have been extenuating circumstances with those, I didn't go read the listings.

Just because I feel charitable, here's a search string to use on that auction site that will get you most of the CGC 1-10s in 9.4, 9,6 ,9.8 that are unsigned in 1 search, plus a few unrelated keyword spamming issues:
(1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10) (9.4,9.6.,9.8) sandman cgc -(ss,signature,signed,pgx,kirby,22)

Send that commission check to....
edited by collectibleshop on 3/25/2019
0 link
Jasonkron
Jasonkron
Posts: 2

3/26/2019

Jasonkron
Jasonkron
Posts: 2
Thank you both so much, this is exactly the info I was looking for. I was hoping that an entire graded run would increase the overall value, and it might, but I'm not sure there are many buyers around who would be willing to pay that much, or i'd be waiting a long time.
0 link