Missing DC COMICS ESSENTIALS-BATMAN: DEATH OF THE Messages in this topic - RSS

jarhead_84
jarhead_84
Posts: 623

1/3/2019

jarhead_84
jarhead_84
Posts: 623
01. TITLE: DC Comics Essentials - Batman: Death Of The Family
02. PUBLISHER: Marvel
03. COUNTRY PUBLISHED: USA
04. COUNTRY PRINTED: USA
05. ISSUE #: 1
06. COVER PRICE: 1.00
07. DATE: June 2016
08. ISSUE NOTES: One Shot
09. PRINT RUN (If Known or Listed):
10. ISBN/ISSN#
Attachments:
DC Essentials.jpg
0 link
jarhead_84
jarhead_84
Posts: 623

2/18/2019

jarhead_84
jarhead_84
Posts: 623
And the status of this one as well?
0 link
Ronbatman
Ronbatman
Administrator
Posts: 2530

2/19/2019

Ronbatman
Ronbatman
Administrator
Posts: 2530
This is a weird one and I'm open to some discussion on it.

No number on the outside
A reprint of issue #13
The cover reprint of issue #15

So some has put this in as Batman #13F because the only difference is the cover. If the indicia says "DC comics Essentials #1" then I would say it needs to be its own title. Thoughts?
R
0 link
BasementComics
BasementComics
Posts: 784

2/19/2019

BasementComics
BasementComics
Posts: 784
Ronbatman wrote:
This is a weird one and I'm open to some discussion on it.

No number on the outside
A reprint of issue #13
The cover reprint of issue #15

So some has put this in as Batman #13F because the only difference is the cover. If the indicia says "DC comics Essentials #1" then I would say it needs to be its own title. Thoughts?
R



I would say it should be its own title but that is me.
0 link
collectibleshop
collectibleshop
Posts: 3088

2/19/2019

collectibleshop
collectibleshop
Posts: 3088
well, looks like ALL the cool kids that have it list it as DC Comics Essentials Batman Death of the Family-- DC Comics own site, Previews solicitation, mycomicshop, amazon, midtown, comicbookrealm, dcfandom, comics.org, comicvine, comicbookdb, etc. etc. And it seems natural, regardless of what the indicia might say, that it's part of the DC Comic Essentials line like it has on the cover in big bold letters, so I'd say the votes are in to list it with the rest of those. Only makes sense, cuz that's how people are going to search for it.

Previews order page for it: https://www.previewsworld.com/Catalog/FEB160221
That plus DC's own site calling it that tells me that's how it should be listed. From the CPG listings for that Essentials title, they're all #1s too, and the whole title makes it clear what it's about, so I don't see what the problem would be calling it that.
edited by collectibleshop on 2/19/2019
0 link
Ronbatman
Ronbatman
Administrator
Posts: 2530

2/20/2019

Ronbatman
Ronbatman
Administrator
Posts: 2530
It's on the site as it's own title now. I cannot delete the 13F yet because 9 people own it on the site. I need to alert them first.
R
0 link
jarhead_84
jarhead_84
Posts: 623

2/20/2019

jarhead_84
jarhead_84
Posts: 623
awesome! Thank you ron!
0 link
Pacino
Pacino
Administrator
Posts: 376

7/1/2021

Pacino
Pacino
Administrator
Posts: 376
Merged the issues
0 link