A CGC certified 9.8 copy of Tales From The Crypt #20 with off-white to white pages sold for $5,000 on eBay. This copy was from the Gaines files and was the first issue of the title Tales From the Crypt. The comic title was formerly known as Crypt of Terror.

The CGC Census currently notes 33 copies certified with the highest graded being five copies tied in 9.8.